In quantum field theory, even defining the entropy of a region of space is more subtle than it first appears. The familiar quantum-mechanical picture, in which a system is described by a density matrix and its entanglement entropy calculated from it, does not carry over straightforwardly to local algebras in quantum field theory. These are typically type III von Neumann algebras, whose mathematical structure rules out that familiar description.
This is not merely a technical inconvenience.
Some lectures become familiar enough to turn into a soundtrack for sleep. Robert Sapolsky’s excellent Stanford course on Human Behavioral Biology has accompanied countless nights of mine, on par with Sidney Coleman’s Harvard Qunatum Field Theory lectures. Few courses reward repetition so well.
The central idea is deceptively simple: human behavior has no single cause.
We like explanations that stop somewhere. A person behaves aggressively because of their hormones, their upbringing, their genes, or the culture they grew up in.
A child rarely has the freedom to decide how to adapt to the world around them. If care is unpredictable, attention may turn toward reading other people’s moods. If anger is dangerous, disagreement may become something to avoid. If affection is conditional, being useful, quiet, successful, or agreeable can begin to feel like the price of belonging.
These adaptations can make sense in the environment where they develop. The difficulty comes when the environment changes but the adaptation remains.
A plastic cap is an oddly small object to carry a model of Europe. Under an EU rule, caps on certain single-use plastic beverage containers must remain attached during intended use1. The environmental rationale is intelligible; so is the everyday irritation. The rule became a meme because it seems to stand for something beyond the cap: a continent that appears increasingly skilled at specifying how existing things should behave, and less convincing at producing the next things the world will depend on.
There is a simple question that sounds too vague to be mathematical: when the same moral judgment is expressed in many different ways, what stays the same?
One culture phrases it one way. A philosophical tradition phrases it another. A vignette, a legal clause, and a proverb can carry the same verdict in different clothes. Philosophy has mostly handled this with more words. This essay is about what happens when you try to handle it with structure instead.
There is an obvious image of coercion: a locked door, a direct threat, a hand preventing someone from leaving. But control does not always need a visible barrier. It can operate through the relationships a person depends on, the reputation they carry, the things they hope for, and the social environment that tells them what they are permitted to feel or want.
The events motivating this essay are not hypothetical. The harder question is how to understand their structure: how individual acts connect, how humiliation and attachment can reinforce one another, and how a social environment can normalize harm by describing it as discipline, protection, correction, or even help.
There is a simple argument against free will, and it is uncomfortable mostly because it is simple. Every event has a cause, or it does not. If it has a cause, you did not author it. If it does not, you did not author it either. There is no third option in which you appear as an uncaused cause, and nobody has ever been able to say what that third option would physically be.
There is a particular kind of tragedy that haunts the foundations of physics and the philosophy of mind. It is not the tragedy of a wrong answer, but of a right question asked in a language no one else could parse—and guarded so fiercely that it was never allowed to be translated. The case of Peter Putnam—a name that should sit alongside Feynman, Everett, and Thorne, yet has been buried in the footnotes of Wheeler’s correspondence.
There is a lot of darkness in the world. History is full of unspeakable acts that humans have done to one another. There are even darker acts that imagining it, is simply impossible, and of course, a lot of it hasn’t even gotten a sentence in history.
There is a kind of strong bond, arguably the strongest form there is, called Traumatic Bonding, which deserves its own article (the Wikipedia article is an excellent one at this topic), but there is also a concept called Weaponized Attachment.
I.
There is a lineage that runs from Spinoza, Einstein, to Putnam, and it is not a lineage of conclusions but of a shared refusal. Spinoza refused to separate mind from nature; he insisted that freedom is not the absence of necessity but the understanding of it. Einstein refused to accept a universe that plays dice; he believed in Spinoza’s God, the orderly harmony of what exists, not a God who concerns himself with the fates of men.